Most people think that “taking someone to court” is the only way to solve a serious legal dispute. As a litigator who has spent decades in the federal and state courts arguing on behalf of his clients, I can say definitively: The courtroom is often the most expensive, slowest, and most stressful place to find a solution.
That is where mediation comes in. If you are facing a business dispute, a contract disagreement, or even a personal legal matter, mediation might be your most powerful tool. Here is what you need to know.
What is Mediation, Exactly?
Mediation is a voluntary process where a neutral third party—the mediator—helps both sides reach a settlement. Crucially, the mediator is not a judge. They don’t decide who is right or wrong, and they don’t issue a ruling. Instead, they facilitate communication to help you find a “middle ground” that everyone can live with.
Why Choose Mediation Over a Trial?
- You Keep Control: In court, a judge or jury—complete strangers—decide your fate. In mediation, you decide. Nothing is final unless you agree.
- It’s Confidential: Court records are public. Mediation is private. What is said in the room stays in the room.
- It’s Faster and Cheaper: Litigation can take years and is expensive. Mediation often can resolve a case in a single day.
When Should You Use Mediation?
Mediation is almost always worth a try, but it is especially effective when:
- Both sides want a solution: If both parties are tired of the conflict and want to move on, mediation succeeds nearly 90% of the time.
- The costs of losing are high: If a “total loss” in court would ruin your business, mediation allows you to mitigate that risk.
- Privacy is paramount: If the dispute involves trade secrets, sensitive family matters, or reputation-damaging allegations, you want to resolve it outside of the public courtroom.
When Should You Avoid Mediation?
While I am an advocate for mediation, it isn’t a magic wand. You might want to skip it (or delay it) if:
- One side is bargaining in bad faith: If the other party is only using mediation to stall for time or to fish for information about your legal strategy, it’s a waste of your resources.
- You need a legal precedent: If you need a court to officially interpret a law to prevent future lawsuits, you need a judge’s ruling, not a private settlement.
- The other side won’t budge: If the opponent’s position is “I’m giving you zero,” there isn’t much for a mediator to work with.
The Bottom Line
Mediation isn’t about “giving in”—it’s about problem-solving. It allows you to stop looking backward at the conflict and start looking forward to your next project.
Before preparing for trial, ask your legal counsel: “Is this a case we can settle through mediation?” Your bottom line—and your stress levels—will thank you.
Kurt Fliegauf is a business litigation attorney, mediator and arbitrator at the Boston-based law firm Conn Kavanaugh Rosenthal Peisch & Ford, LLP
He can be reached at kfliegauf@connkavanaugh.com
Share with your network:
